Development, simulation testing, and implementation of management
procedures for data-limited fisheries
(see Carruthers & Hordyk (2018)
DLMtool is a R package for management strategy evalaution and implementation of data-limited fishery stock assessment methods.
Find more information about DLMtool at http://datalimitedtoolkit.org/.
The released version of
DLMtool can be downloaded from CRAN:
This GitHub repository contains the development version of DLMtool. The development version may be unstable, and it is not recommended for analyses.
A User Guide for the DLMtool package are now available: https://dlmtool.github.io/DLMtool/userguide/introduction.html.
The current version of the DLMtool package is available for download from CRAN.
runMSEfunction is now more robust. MPs that fail (i.e. crash R) are now skipped without stopping the entire MSE. A warning message alerts users which MPs have been dropped from the analysis.
runMSE(Hist=TRUE)returns a new S4 object of class 'Hist'. This change means that information from historical simulations is now accessed using
$. For example:
Hist <- runMSE(Hist=TRUE)
TS <- [email protected] # time-series data
Data <- [email protected] # Data object from end of historical period
runMSE(Hist=TRUE)now works with parallel processing
Usesfunction has been added to return MPs that use a particular data slot. For example:
PMObjhave been added to generate interacive HTML tables showing the performance of MPs (using objects of class
Labelshas been added to the
TradePlotfunction and related functions (
Tplotetc). This allows users to replace the default MP name with something more user-friendly. For example:
TradePlot(MSE, Labels=list(AvC="Average Catch")). An argument
colshas also been added so users have full control on the colors of the points and labels. The MP labels can be removed completely by setting the
[email protected]) have been removed. Time-varying parameters should now be specified with
AnnualMSYargument is now deprecated. MSY reference points are now always calculated in every time-step.
runMSErobustfunction has been now removed from package (it was broken in the previous version).
Dataobjects with larger number of length bins
curE75which was ratcheting down effort
plotMPAto include relative size of areas
[email protected]has been updated to only include historical conditions.
XL2Datato read files from other than working directory
[email protected] == 1
[email protected]can now be a vector of length
nMPs, to specify different management intervals for different MPs. For example, with
runMSE(OM, MPs=c('AvC', 'BK')),AvC
is applied every year andBK
is applied every 5 years.[email protected]` is recycled if not the same length as number of MPs.
makeMeanMPhas been added to generate a MP that averages output from a list of other MPs.
Turinghas been added to compare simulated data from an OM to the real data in the fishery Data object.
predictLHhave been added to predict correlated life-history parameters from FishBase using FishLife model.
Replacefunction has been updated to replace directly from individual Stock, Fleet, Obs, and Imp objects instead of from only OM objects
summary(Data)function have been improved
makePerfhas been replaced with
tinyErrfunction with options to remove process error, observation error, and gradients
PM(Performance Metric) methods have been updated and described in the user guide
Feasehas been simplified and updated. Fease object has now been removed
plotand examples in the online documentation
[email protected]) have been updated and now have better documentation
userguide()has been updated and additional chapters added on new features
Region, and for data-rich MPs in MSEtool:
runsMSE(parallel=TRUE)and cluster hasn't been initialized
Mixed MPs: it is now possible to design MPs that combine Output and Input controls. Previously, MPs in DLMtool where either class 'Input' or class 'Output'. This has changed, and all MPs are now class 'MP' and return a standard recommendation object ('Rec') that allows specification of any combination of catch limit, effort limit, spatial closure, and size-at-selection and/or size-at-retention regulations.
MP types: For convenience, MPs can be categorised into 4 types: 'Output' (only catch limits), 'Input' (only spatial, effort, and/or size regulations), 'Mixed' (some combination of Output and Input regulations), and 'Reference' (MPs such as FMSYref or NFref which are designed to be used a references and not for actual applications). The function
MPtype can be used to determine an MP's type, e.g
Increased flexibility of selectivity, retention, and discard mortality controls: MPs can now modify both selectivity and retention curves, and also modify the level of discard mortality.
Historical MPAs: A new slot
MPA has been added to the
Fleet object. This allows users to specify the historical year and the fraction of an area that was closed. See
?plotMPA for an example.
Improvements to MSY reference point calculations: MSY reference points are now calculate for every year. This accounts for changes in productivity (e.g., increases in growth) that affect reference points such as BMSY and FMSY.
Increased number of areas: By default DLMtool is a 2-area model. The code has now been updated to include more areas if required.
Movement by age: It is now possible to specify movement by age, such as ontogenetic migration offshore
runMSE has been optimized for parallel processing. By default, parallel processing is not used if
nsim<=48. We suggest testing your OM with a low number of simulations (e.g
nsim=48) and then increasing the number of simulations and using parallel processing:
runMSE(OM, MPs, parallel=TRUE). Update messages are not displayed in parallel mode.
Taxonomic information: New slots have been added to the
Stock object to record common name and taxonomic details.
Converge function has been updated with a improved of convergence diagnostics.
A new performance metric (
PM) class has been added. This allows users to develop a custom set of performance metrics for their management system. A series of example
PM objects have been created (see
avail('PM')). Over time the summary and plotting functions will be updated to take a set of
PM objects. See
Tplot3 for an example.
Many improvements to functions (e.g MPs) to improve robustness and avoid model crashes due to stochastic sampling of parameters.
All code in DLMtool is now tested using the
testthat package to ensure that the functions work as expected. Please continue to file bug reports at: https://github.com/DLMtool/DLMtool/issues
The User Manual has been completely revised and updated. Use
userguide() to access. Please submit any typo corrections or suggestions for improvement at https://github.com/DLMtool/DLMtool_UserGuide/issues. Pull requests are welcome.
We are developing an online library of DLMtool OMs (http://www.datalimitedtoolkit.org/fishery_library) which has the OM Report, OM Excel file, and OM R data object for each DLMtool OM. A standardized MSE report is in development. The OM library will be expanded as new OMs are developed. Please contact us if you have developed OMs and are able to make them publicly available.
A DLMtool user forum is in development and will be launched soon. The idea of the forum is to provide a platform for DLMtool users to ask questions and share experience with each other and the DLMtool team.
The following slots have been added to the OM object:
This was done so that an OM object is completely self-contained and includes all information used in the MSE.
Objects names have been shortened and modified for consistency:
Implementation error and a dedicated implementation error object called 'Imp', (like Stock, Fleet and Obs) that can account for variability and overages/underages in both effort, catch and size limit advice (discarding rate and post release mortality rate are coming soon)
At least 10 new example operating models from real DLMtool applications in the US and Canada
Stochastic SRA operating model functions (i.e. build a full operating model accounting for correlations in parameters using historical catch trends and some composition data)
Full plots of operating model conditions
Stock-synthesis assessment to DLM function for specifying operating models (currently MLE only but adding MCMC and hessian options)
iSCAM assessment to DLM support for specifying operating models (MPD only but adding MCMC and hessian options soon)
Tracking of historical versus current simulated age composition in catches and population over simulations
New function 'Replace' for copying parts of an operating model to another operating model (e.g. Robin Hood approach,where you may want to borrow say, the fleet characteristics from another operating model)
Estimation of a new reference point 'Blow' for calculation of conservation-related performance metrics (Blow is the spawning biomass where it takes HZN number of mean generation times to reach Bfrac fraction of SSBMSY given zero catches, where the user can specify HZN and Bfrac).
Canadian DFO performance plots (DFO_hist, DFO_proj, DFO_plot2)
Biomass recovery relative to Blow plots (COSEWIC_plot)
A dedicated custom parameters slot in the operating model object. This is a list where the user can place custom parameters samples (from any distribution / correlation structure you wish) that are named as they appear in the operating model.
DLMdathave now been added as separate data objects. This means that it is no longer neccessary to unpack data objects at the beginning of an R session.
runMSErobustfunctions have a new logical argument
Hist=TRUEthe model returns the historical simulations only.
CheckConverghas been deprecated - use
Convergenow to check MSE for convergence
runMSE.rand renamed parameters to match OM object
R0can be a vector
customparshas been moved in the MSE code so that more parameters can be passed in to the MSE. A message alerts users which valid parameters have been found in
customparsand any invalid parameters are displayed in a warning message
SSBMSY_SSB0to avoid confusion
SSBand vulnerable biomass
VBto MSE object
SpAbunslot to data object for abundance of spawning stock. The
Abunslot relates to vulnerable biomass
fracDcontrol arguments to
runMSE. Allows user to modify the maximum number of re-samples in the optimization to achieve the sampled depletion. The model will stop if a proprtion greater than
fracDof the simulated depletion values are not the same as the sampled values after more than
ChooseEffortfunction where nyears was being set to 0 in some cases
hcvis 0 in the runMSE code
FMSYrefresults in exactly F/FSMY = 1
maxFnow also applies to the catch that is taken from the population
A number of additional plotting functions, and a few new MPs have been added in this version. Also a few minor changes to improve performance and reliability of the model.
For improved stability, especially with large files, the
runMSErobust function has been changed so that it now uses the
saveRDS function to write the MSE objects to disk. MSE objects saved with this version of the function need to be loaded with
plotFun function can be used to print out all available plotting functions for objects of class
Pplot and Kplot functions have been modified for extra control of various features of the plots.
boxplot.MSE, have been added to plot the MSE object. Call them using the generic
boxplot functions, and see
?boxplot.MSE for information on the arguments for the function.
VOIplot have been added.
boxplot.DLM_data has been added and can be used to plot boxplots of the TACs recommendations from different methods. Call with
Three new input control methods, developed by Helena Geremont, have been added to the package:
A new slot (Effort) has been added to the MSE object. This stores the fishing effort for each year, simulation, and MP in the projection years. The addition of the new slot may cause a warning message to be thrown up if an MSE object from a previous version of the DLMtool is loaded.
You can update the old MSE object by adding an empty
MSEobj <- updateMSE(MSEobj).
There were some issues with a couple of the input control MPs, which have now been addressed (thanks, Helena, for identifying these). There was also a problem with effort and selectivity being calculated for the input controls, which has also been fixed.
A number of small but important bugs have been fixed, with special thanks to Liz Brooks, Helena Geromont, and Bill Harford for alerting us to some of these issues.
Quang Huynh has recoded the mean length methods in C++, and they now run much faster, so should pass the time-limit constraint.
A new function (
runMSErobust) has been added which is a wrapper for the
runMSE function. In time, this may replace
runMSE as the primary function to use when running a MSE.
runMSErobust splits large simulations into a series of smaller packets and stitches them together to return an MSE object. This has the benefit of increasing speed and efficiency, particularly for runs with large number of simulations. The function also checks for errors and re-starts the MSE if the model crashes.
A set of functions
Fease_xl have been added. These are used to read in operating model and feasibility parameters from an Excel spreadsheet rather than a CSV file. These are essentially wrappers for the
new function, but allow you to store all operating model tables in a single spreadsheet rather than a number of CSV files. This is mainly useful if you are working on multiple species/stocks.
The size limit feature has been updated to include an upper slot limit. See
slotlim for an example MP. The slot limit is specified as the last element in the input control vector. Similar to the lower size limit, all individuals above the slot limit experience no fishing mortality.
A number of new MPs have been added. There are now 63 output and 22 input control MPs in the DLMtool.
A new function
makePerf has been added. This function takes an OM object, and returns the same OM object with no process or observation error. This is useful for testing the performance of methods under perfect conditions, to see if they work as expected. And for debugging!
Two new plotting functions have been added:
wormplot which creates worm plots of the likelihood of meeting biomass targets in future years, and
VOIplot which is another value of information plot, similar to the
VOI function, and shows how observation and operating model parameter values affect trends in long-term yield and biomass.
Coming soon: bag limit MPs for recreational fisheries
In order to simulate fisheries that have experienced important shifts in historical length selectivity, this can now be user specified using a graphical user interface (the 'ChooseSelect' function) or by manually editing a series of new slots in the Fleet object (
Persistent shifts in stock productivity are a particular concern for fishery management. These can now be generated in the toolkit using a new function
SetRecruitCycle that generates cyclical pattern in recruitment strength.
Length-based spawning potential ratio (SPR) MPs have been added. Currently these methods are slow and often don't pass the time constraint.
Two features have been added to allow MPs to return additional information for future reference. (1) The DLM_data object that MPs operate on now has a miscellaneous slot
Misc. (2) MPs can now return a list. The first position is the management recommendation (e.g. TAC) the second is information that is stored in the
Misc slot that can be used by the MP in the next iteration. This can be useful for storing information that is time-consuming to calculate each year.
A new generic trade-off performance plot
TradePlot has also been added.
Operating model effort is now simulated by a time-series of year vertices and relative magnitude of effort at each vertex. It follows that the slot
[email protected], and has been replaced by three slots with vectors of equal length:
[email protected] and
[email protected]. These effort trajectories can now be specified by a new graphical interface (function
ChooseEffort()) which uses points to determine the three slots described above.
Operating model fleet selectivity has been robustified to prevent users from specifying length at first capture (
[email protected]) and length at full selection (
[email protected]) that are unrealistically high. According to our view of reality these now have upper limits of L50 and maximum length, respectively.
DOM() has been added that evaluates how often one MP outperforms another across simulations. It is possible that an MP could have higher average performance but perform worse on higher fraction of simulations. The
DOM() function provides a diagnostic to analyze this.
An additional function
Sub() has been added which allows users to subset an MSE object according to either (or both) a vector of MPs and simulations. This means you no longer have to rerun everything to provide results for a smaller number of MPs or particular simulations.
A bug was found in which length at first capture was being sampled from a uniform distribution
U(LB,UB*2) rather than
U(LB,UB). When depletion could not be simulated by even very high fishery catchabilities an error could occur after more than 10 attempts to find a suitable value of depletion. Length composition simulation in 2.1.1 was not correctly implemented leading to minor biases.
In response to popular demand, simulation and data are entirely length-based now. It follows that many objects that worked with 2.0 will no longer be compatible. In most cases it is very quick to make files/objects compatible with version 2.1, but nonetheless we apologize if this is frustrating!
The DLMtool package is stochastic, so if you run into problems with the code, please report them (along with a random seed). In the meantime, simply try running it again; the problem may be attributable to a rare combination of sampled parameters.
Be warned that if you abort a parallel process (e.g.
runMSE()) half-way through, you are in the lap of the gods! It will often be necessary to restart the cluster
sfInit() or even restart R.
The package is not designed for very short lived stocks (that live for less than 5 years) due to the problems with approximating fine-scale temporal dynamics with an annual model. Technically, you could just divide all your parameters by a sub-year resolution, but the TAC would be set by sub-year and the data would also be available at this fine-scale, which is highly unlikely in a data-limited setting.
(1) The DLMtool has moved to a length-based simulator (maturity, fisheries selectivity by length)
(2) The spatial targeting function has been removed for the moment as its implementation was flawed , so could not distribute fishing correctly with respect to both density and the amount of the resource among the two areas.
Tplot2 adds a different set of trade-offs including long-term and short-term probability of achieving 50% of FMSY yield and average annual variability in yields.
(4) Version 2.0 did not include observation error in estimates of current stock abundance and depletion (only biases were simulated). Many thanks to Helena Geromont for spotting this. This has now been corrected.
DLM_data objects now have a slot
LHYear which is a numeric value corresponding with the last historical year. This is needed for some MPs that want to run off only the past data rather than the updated (projected, closed-loop simulation) data.
(6) Post-MSE, you can now run a Convergence function
CheckConverg() to see if performance metrics are stable.
(7) The package now contains
CSRA, a tool for calculating very rough estimates of current depletion and fishing mortality rate from mean catch data.
getAFC now can be used for converting length estimates to age estimates through a stochastic growth model.
(9) The value of information function (
VOI) contained bugs in version 2.0. This now has been fixed.
(10) Users can now send their own parameter values to the
runMSE function allowing outputs from stock assessments or correlated parameters (e.g. K and age at maturity) values.
(11) After deliberation, Pope's approximation has been used to account for intra-year mortality (i.e., TACs are taken from biomass at the start of the year subject to half of natural mortality rate). This is probably a reasonable approximation in a data-limited setting: alternative structural assumptions for M are eclipsed by uncertainty in M itself and other operating model parameters such as selectivity and bias in observation of data such as annual catches.
(12) The simulation of length composition data was bugged in version 2.0. The variability in length at age was taken from the observation model. Using the perfect information observation model therefore led to no variability in length at age and hence very odd length composition data. This has been solved; now a fixed 10% CV in length-at-age is assumed (normally distributed).
(13) A bug with Delay-Difference MPs has been fixed (
DD4010) in which stochastic TACs were sampled when reps =1. This should just be the mean estimate. The result is that DD is much less variable between years but comes with less contrast in the data. In addition to the much less variable catch recommendations, long-term mean performance of the MP is reduced while medium-term performance has been improved.
(14) In the move to length-based inputs it is possible to prescribe wild biases for maximum length and length at maturity. In this version these sampled biases are not correlated so it is possible to create simulated data sets where maximum length is lower than length-at-95% maturity and length-at-50% maturity. We put a hard ceiling on this such that length at 95 percent maturity must be below 90 percent of maximum length and length-at-50% maturity must be below 90% of length-at-95% maturity. This isn't great and this will be improved for v2.11.
(15) The package now works without initiating a cluster
(16) A simple modification to
DCAC has been added
EDCAC (Harford and Carruthers, 2015) that better accounts for absolute stock depletion.
(17) Three new slots are available to run MPs on that related to mean length of catches (
ML), modal length of captures (
Lc), and the mean length of catches of fish over
(1) Much has changed in the DLMtool terminology to make it more generally applicable. For example, OFL (overfishing limits, FMSY x current biomass), now belongs to a larger class of TACs (Total Allowable Catches).
(2) There are now just two classes of DLM MPs, DLM_output (MPs linked to output controls e.g. TACs) and DLM_input (MPs linked to input controls such as time-area closures, age selectivity and effort). The new DLM_input function classes have four components, fractional reallocation of spatial effort, fraction of effort in final historical year prescribed in the current year, spatial limits on fishing mortality and a user-defined age-selectivity curve. For example, given an hypothetical stock with 8 age classes a DLM_input method might return a vector c(0.5, 0.8, 0,1, 0,0,0,0,1,1,1,1). This is interpreted as a 50% reallocation (Allocation = 0.5) of spatial effort, with a total effort that is 80% of historical levels (Effort = 0.8) with a closure in area 1 and full fishing in area 2 (Spatial = c(0,1)) and knife-edge selectivity at age class 5 (Selectivity = c(0,0,0,0,1,1,1,1)) [note that Selectivity has changed in newer versions of the package]. To demonstrate this new feature there are four new input controls, current effort (curE), 75% of current effort (curE75), age selectivity that matches the maturity ogive (matagelim) and a marine reserve in area 1 (area1MR) [note that matagelim has changed to matlenlim in recent versions].
(3) A 'dumb' MP has been added: Mean Catch Depletion (MCD) that simply calculates a TAC based on mean catches and depletion. This is to demonstrate the (theoretically) very high information content of a reliable estimate of current stock depletion.
(4) A better length composition simulator has been added. Note that this still renews the normal length structure between ages and does not properly simulate the higher mortality rate of larger, faster growing fish (a growth type group simulator is on its way).
(5) Help documentation has been much improved including complete guides for
MSE objects. Eg
(6) Minor bugs have been found with the help of Helena Geromont including a problem with update intervals of 1 and low simulated steepness values.
(7) Reliability is much improved following a full combinatorial test of all Fleet, Stock, Observation objects against all MPs.
(8) A dedicated Value of information function is now available for MSE objects:
VOI(MSEobject) which is smarter than the former version which was included in plot(MSE object class).
(9) Plotting functions have been improved, particularly
plot(DLM_data object class).
SPmod has been robustified to stop strongly negative surplus production estimates from leading to erratic behavior.
(11) The butterfish stock type now has less variable recruitment and slightly lower natural mortality rate as previous values were rather extreme and led to data generation errors (with natural mortality rate as high as 0.9, butterfish is right at the limit of what can be simulated reasonably with an annual age-structured operating model).